Skip to content

Derivations: a closed-form reference for the (n,2n) Legendre transfer binding (sn-n2n-transfer-binding is a sentinel) #451

Description

@deOliveira-R

The gap (archivist, #426 step 3, 2026-09-04)

derivations/ has no script for the (n,2n) Legendre stack: every number the transfer family is verified against is either an end-to-end SN solve (the Be-reflected flagship, tests/sn/verification/analytical/test_be_reflected_n2n_anisotropy.py) or a tape read (tests/data/test_n2n_yield_convention.py). The corpus pass scored the family's "derivation source" dimension 3/6 for that reason, and sn-n2n-transfer-binding (the per-ℓ (n,2n) binding equation in docs/theory/methods/sn/adjoint.rst) is a documented SENTINEL — implemented, not verified by a foundation edge.

What would close it, in cost order

  1. Cheap, term tier. A SymPy derive_*() in orpheus/derivations/ proving emission_matrix(y=2) ≡ 2·emission_matrix(y=1) and, more usefully, that the per-ℓ (n,2n) source is y·Σ_{2n,ℓ}ᵀ φ_ℓ block by block — the F2 ruling as algebra — with a verifies("sn-n2n-transfer-binding") marker. Moves the label from sentinel to a real foundation edge in the V&V matrix.
  2. Eigenvalue tier. An ANISOTROPIC extension of derive_2g_n2n (the existing 2-group infinite-medium (n,2n) case, orpheus/derivations/continuous/analytical/homogeneous.py): a P1 (n,2n) block in an infinite medium changes k only through the leakage-free P1 closure, so the honest reference is a P1/B1 infinite-medium solve with a scattering-order-1 (n,2n) term — the only route that reaches the eigenvalue layer with a closed form (an MMS would not: the (n,2n) anisotropy is a streaming-coupled source, and MMS verifies discretization, not the model).
  3. Not worth it: an ℓ ≥ 2 closed form — the flagship's ladder converges by ℓ = 1 ([M] |Δ(ℓ=2)|/|Δ(ℓ=1)| = 3.1e-3).

Context: .claude/plans/n2n_anisotropy_kept.md §5b.3; ERR-082 in the error catalogue.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    module:derivationsderivations/ reference valuesmodule:sn02.Discrete.Ordinatestype:improvementEnhancement to existing functionality

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions