Skip to content

Ban-pick: weighted tuple pool policy per gamemode (Botlatro generation parity) #13

Description

@ChronoFinale

The ban-pick engine's default pool is a uniform random sample of every installed deck Back — including modded decks — with no exclusions, no weights, and no stake dimension. Botlatro (the Discord matchmaking bot) already runs real pool policy for its tuple-ban queues; this issue is about giving consumer mods the same power in-game, per mod and per gamemode.

Reference: what Botlatro's generation enforces (src/utils/TupleBans.ts)

  • Allowed stakes: a fixed subset (White/Green/Black/Purple/Gold — 5 of 8).
  • Allowed decks: decks table minus per-queue banned_decks minus match-step bans.
  • Weighted roulette-wheel selection via per-queue deck_mults / stake_mults.
  • Occurrence caps in the generated list (9 tuples): max 4 of any stake (< (tupleCount-1)/2), max 3 of any deck (< (tupleCount-3)/2), no duplicate (deck, stake) pairs.
  • White-stake guarantee: if the final slot is reached with zero whites, it is forced white — every list contains at least one.
  • All of it is data-driven (DB tables) so moderators tune weights/bans live, without a deploy.

Proposal

  1. A reusable weighted-tuple pool helper in the API (opt-in, e.g. MPAPI.BanPick.build_weighted_pool(policy)), implementing the constraints above and returning { key, stake } items. The engine already supports everything downstream of it: pool items may be { key, stake, ... } tables, and config.decorate_tile(card, item) renders stake stickers — no engine changes needed.
  2. Policy comes from the consumer, per gamemode — each mod passes its own policy into BP.start via build_pool, exactly like schedule/decorate_tile today. PvP and Speedrun configure independently.
  3. Policy data should be server-deliverable (gamemode config in the match/lobby payload, keyed by modId + gameMode) so allowed lists/weights can be tuned like the bot's DB-backed mults — without shipping mod updates. Client-side defaults as fallback.

Notes

  • Sampling differs today: the in-game default samples decks without replacement (each deck once); tuple pools intentionally allow one deck at multiple stakes. Both remain valid choices per gamemode — the helper covers the tuple case, the current default stays for plain drafts.
  • Related: the low-rated-player pool veto (see linked issue) depends on this — its mercy rule ("force white stakes into the reroll") only has meaning against a weighted tuple pool.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions